Tuesday, March 12, 2013
Final Thoughts....Waiting for Superman
It seemed like most people featured in this movie were indeed just waiting for something better. These students are depending on it. Even those students who are very young knew what the outcome meant...success, or failure. This movie made me very sad, sad for the public, students, parents, teachers and those who do not have access to such wonderful programs as I did growing up. It is truly heartbreaking. Makes me wonder why aren't there more people like Geoffrey Canada? I will probably never forget this mans name. This movie reinforced my desire to become a teacher. There were many different possibilities introduced as far as what "the problem" is with our public schools. The blame was put upon the Teachers Union, the rules of the districts, states, and federal government, the teachers, and the location of the students. One main problem that I sided with that I will go on to write about in my 3rd paper is teacher proficiency. There are a certain kind of teachers that gathered at these innovative schools where the lottery's were held to determine the new students. These innovative teachers are there for different reasons than an average or below average teacher who is dependant on tenure. I am confused about how hard it can be for some citizens of this country. It is not localized only in New York or D.C, these problem schools or dropout factories are located all over the United States.
Thursday, March 7, 2013
what is the most important change that k-12 education needs?
I have come up with more than one idea as to what I believe is the most important change needed in k-12. The first thing is the home/school connection. I believe that if there is a bigger and more evenly understood connection between home and school then our students will have more encouragement to continue their learning at home. Although many factors will get in the way. There is no way to guarantee that all home lives are similar, which is why I think that if there is more involvement from the school reaching out to understand each individual home life then children will feel more encouragement to succeed. There are at risk families who may need more help than others.
Another idea I have is to change the way we educate our teachers in an ongoing fashion. Allow teachers to have more trainings and mentoring available to them. I have seen examples of this at my sons school, where I recently did an interview with his teacher and was given some insight to what these teachers have available to them on a daily basis. I think that is part of the reason that his school is so valued by the community.I have witnessed student teachers, para educators, and in class advocates for those in need at his school. This seems to work to bridge the gap between home and school as well as provide teachers with a round table like place to bounce ideas off of one another.
There should be more teachers, or para educators, or "experienced" volunteers being the thresh hold between home and school.
Another idea I have is to change the way we educate our teachers in an ongoing fashion. Allow teachers to have more trainings and mentoring available to them. I have seen examples of this at my sons school, where I recently did an interview with his teacher and was given some insight to what these teachers have available to them on a daily basis. I think that is part of the reason that his school is so valued by the community.I have witnessed student teachers, para educators, and in class advocates for those in need at his school. This seems to work to bridge the gap between home and school as well as provide teachers with a round table like place to bounce ideas off of one another.
There should be more teachers, or para educators, or "experienced" volunteers being the thresh hold between home and school.
"Against School"
This was a very interesting read, one that quoted many famous historical figures and provided a whole bunch of proof. After reading this I realize even more what the task at hand is with our 3rd paper. When Gatto starts to explain either a support or a contradictory part of his research he uses other works to back himself up. The idea of boredom at school and the remedy that children must carry that life within themselves seems very true to me. I grew up on a dirt road, away from my friends, and no kids around to play with. I was never bored. I feel like I was introduced to many many things by just being outside, writing poetry, playing make believe and learning through curiosity and self entertainment. John Gatto gave so many specifics to why school is viewed the way that it is. I agree with the initial goals introduced, 1.to make good people 2. to make good citizens and 3. to make each person his or her own personal best. But are these things we see as a constant guide to teaching? Not exactly. With the introduction of the easy entertainment and consumerism in this paper those core goals are overlooked a bit. We will not inspire good people, or citizenship or our best possible achievements with instant gratification. There is a large part of independent research and self enrichment that is lost within the world of computers, online shopping, google research, and television. Gattos comparison with Ben Franklin whom we read about previously proves the difference in today's learning standards and those standards that were undefined in Ben Franklin's time. I got a many good ideas from this paper to further research and use towards building my 3rd paper.
Rose vs. Black
From the article "resolutions someone should make for 2011" Mike Rose explains the things he would change in order to reverse the bad habits of the past, and change the school system for the better. I agree that we "should stop the accountability train" and really look into what makes each student an achiever. There are many achievements in school that may not be textbook "right" but may hold just as much value and importance as standardized tests. I had never thought about the idea of having a standardized test to judge any other professionals in their workplace. I also learned that sometimes these famous figures that are sent to report on a something to do with education may not be qualified to do so, for example the president coming to California to talk about education and then meeting with Steve Jobs? That makes almost no sense besides the fact that Steve Jobs was educated, the only correlation I see there.
In the video starring Lewis Black he shows different excerpts from reality TV show that portray American Education...my first thought, why are we using a child's education as a form of entertainment? The amount of money that goes into making these reality TV shows seems like a waste to me. He shows different reporters commentating on education, one says "we are going to dedicate this whole week to education" just a week? Why not a lifetime? Schools in America, especially in lower income areas are broken. The fact that these wonderful charter schools are being designed and legalized in many states across the country doesn't necessarily mean anyone we know has access to them. It is a "lottery" to get in like he said.
The article by Rose states " There are many factors that affect student academic performance, and the largest is parental income" Such a sad reality. This is shown in the clip with Lewis Black as well, 578,000,000 dollars for a school?! I am sure those kids are receiving better than average education because their community can afford to employ that kind of teacher, and promote that kind of consistency much more than a low income area.
In the video starring Lewis Black he shows different excerpts from reality TV show that portray American Education...my first thought, why are we using a child's education as a form of entertainment? The amount of money that goes into making these reality TV shows seems like a waste to me. He shows different reporters commentating on education, one says "we are going to dedicate this whole week to education" just a week? Why not a lifetime? Schools in America, especially in lower income areas are broken. The fact that these wonderful charter schools are being designed and legalized in many states across the country doesn't necessarily mean anyone we know has access to them. It is a "lottery" to get in like he said.
The article by Rose states " There are many factors that affect student academic performance, and the largest is parental income" Such a sad reality. This is shown in the clip with Lewis Black as well, 578,000,000 dollars for a school?! I am sure those kids are receiving better than average education because their community can afford to employ that kind of teacher, and promote that kind of consistency much more than a low income area.
Notes on Chalk
In the introduction a man is sharing the reasons why this movie means so much to him, he says he was surrounded by teachers his whole life. His mother, aunts, and other relatives were all teachers. They complained, but they loved being teachers. This movie takes place in time periods; first day of school, 34 weeks until summer, one week before spring break, etc. but my notes do not go in this form. My notes on the movie were taken and classified by the teacher, and then by the main ideas that I got from the movie.
On the first day of school each teacher is introduced. Mr. Stroop is a 3rd year History teacher, he begins his school year asking students how they spent their summer, making them laugh, and it seems like he has a connection with these students. He has a meeting with an obvious superior discussing his goals from the last years meeting. He hasn't improved his lesson planning, or his organization or sarcasm. " But the kids like the lesson" is his answer to why he doesn't follow and plan a specific outline for each class. Mr. Stroop had been told before he began teaching as a piece of advice, "don't be their friend" but he had found that he wants the students to trust him and bond with him.
He is hard to take seriously, there is a scene where he is asking his students to tone down their intelligence, not to use big words, and not to correct him even though he may be wrong. There is a scene of him out shooting targets, he says"do your best, your not going to get every kid" referring to shooting his targets and the amount of kids that succeed in high school. "6 out of 10 get a college degree...i tried" he says. He shows great concern in being voted teacher of the year, seems as though more effort is put towards that than towards the curriculum in his History class. When he loses this election he shows his rage and loss of control in front of his classroom of students
Mr Lowry is a first year teacher who seems to have come from basically no training at all. Right away the students know he is new, they ask him how long he has been a teacher and he replies "1.5 hours." He stumbles over his words, jumps back and forth between subjects, and shows his frustration and confusion all over his face. He checks out a book on classroom management to try to help himself find control, the kids joke alot, laugh, and hide his chalk from him. No one in this class seems to be learning. Then one day he agrees to be in the Spelling Hornet, the slang words spelling bee ran by the students that the teachers study for and compete in. He wins, with the help of his history class that came together to help him. They bonded and as a result we saw a huge change in the classroom dynamics. Its as though the kids did not respect him or consider his personality until he let them see it, let down his guard and poof, he was respected after that. His frustration showed greatly when there was a cell phone incident in class, Mr Lowry lost his temper and used cuss words, then went to the students home and bonded with his mother, didn't seem to solve anything except drive in the nail that he was inexperienced and lost within his job.
Coach Webb had the right idea on how to teach I believe, her students responded to her and she laughed with them, also holding control over her classroom at the same time. She said "you make students understand their expectations and suddenly they perform at that level". At the same time her skills at interacting with other teachers and staff were not so great. Many staff members confided in the A.P that Coach Webb was pushy, and condescending. She seemed very concerned about the little things, hall passes, food in the lounge fridge, more so than academics or physical education. She thought that having her best friend serving as the new Assistant Principle would help her to have more dependency on administration, that she could complain about something and her friend would help her out. There were multiple scenes when Coach Webb would be complaining about how things were done, that things "should Be in black and white, no grey area". In the end of the movie she does a little soul searching and decides that "I need to try and approach people differently, try to encourage them instead of coming down on them"
The Assistant Principle in this movie went from teaching traditionally in the classroom to administration when a position became available. Right away you can see that the Principle, her superior is more willing to talk about his interests, and his life than he is to talk about her duties. He remains very vague and tells her to expect to spend many hours here, even some Saturdays. She becomes overwhelmed pretty early on as she is being bombarded with complaints by staff. Instead of being able to focus on academia she is always fighting a battle for someone. She mentions towards the end of the school year that she has been focusing so much on the "bad kids it makes her realize how much she misses teaching those who do care" She talks about academics and children learning the lessons in her class more than any other teacher. There is a scene in the end when she says schools need more nurturing, but it starts at home, a place that she herself had not been spending enough time focusing on.
Throughout the movie the teachers spend some down time visiting in the lounge, they go out for drinks together, and that bonding between staff is something I agree with. Within this school there is no clear lines of who does what, or what is allowed. No consistency in a school can affect teachers, staff and students. Some teachers are appearing to be putting tons of effort into their class, while others appear to be lacking. The teachers in this movie complained and spoke more about each other than they did about teaching students. Even during the teacher of the year debate we heard topics including, copiers for every teacher, less faculty meetings, corporal punishment which had no relevancy to this school. The teachers were more passionate about improving their working conditions than improving the children's learning conditions.
Watching this movie made me realize that teachers are always faced with their own trial as they are human like anyone else, but the focus needs to remain on the students, learning, and especially bonding since students are much more willing to listen when they respect you.
On the first day of school each teacher is introduced. Mr. Stroop is a 3rd year History teacher, he begins his school year asking students how they spent their summer, making them laugh, and it seems like he has a connection with these students. He has a meeting with an obvious superior discussing his goals from the last years meeting. He hasn't improved his lesson planning, or his organization or sarcasm. " But the kids like the lesson" is his answer to why he doesn't follow and plan a specific outline for each class. Mr. Stroop had been told before he began teaching as a piece of advice, "don't be their friend" but he had found that he wants the students to trust him and bond with him.
He is hard to take seriously, there is a scene where he is asking his students to tone down their intelligence, not to use big words, and not to correct him even though he may be wrong. There is a scene of him out shooting targets, he says"do your best, your not going to get every kid" referring to shooting his targets and the amount of kids that succeed in high school. "6 out of 10 get a college degree...i tried" he says. He shows great concern in being voted teacher of the year, seems as though more effort is put towards that than towards the curriculum in his History class. When he loses this election he shows his rage and loss of control in front of his classroom of students
Mr Lowry is a first year teacher who seems to have come from basically no training at all. Right away the students know he is new, they ask him how long he has been a teacher and he replies "1.5 hours." He stumbles over his words, jumps back and forth between subjects, and shows his frustration and confusion all over his face. He checks out a book on classroom management to try to help himself find control, the kids joke alot, laugh, and hide his chalk from him. No one in this class seems to be learning. Then one day he agrees to be in the Spelling Hornet, the slang words spelling bee ran by the students that the teachers study for and compete in. He wins, with the help of his history class that came together to help him. They bonded and as a result we saw a huge change in the classroom dynamics. Its as though the kids did not respect him or consider his personality until he let them see it, let down his guard and poof, he was respected after that. His frustration showed greatly when there was a cell phone incident in class, Mr Lowry lost his temper and used cuss words, then went to the students home and bonded with his mother, didn't seem to solve anything except drive in the nail that he was inexperienced and lost within his job.
Coach Webb had the right idea on how to teach I believe, her students responded to her and she laughed with them, also holding control over her classroom at the same time. She said "you make students understand their expectations and suddenly they perform at that level". At the same time her skills at interacting with other teachers and staff were not so great. Many staff members confided in the A.P that Coach Webb was pushy, and condescending. She seemed very concerned about the little things, hall passes, food in the lounge fridge, more so than academics or physical education. She thought that having her best friend serving as the new Assistant Principle would help her to have more dependency on administration, that she could complain about something and her friend would help her out. There were multiple scenes when Coach Webb would be complaining about how things were done, that things "should Be in black and white, no grey area". In the end of the movie she does a little soul searching and decides that "I need to try and approach people differently, try to encourage them instead of coming down on them"
The Assistant Principle in this movie went from teaching traditionally in the classroom to administration when a position became available. Right away you can see that the Principle, her superior is more willing to talk about his interests, and his life than he is to talk about her duties. He remains very vague and tells her to expect to spend many hours here, even some Saturdays. She becomes overwhelmed pretty early on as she is being bombarded with complaints by staff. Instead of being able to focus on academia she is always fighting a battle for someone. She mentions towards the end of the school year that she has been focusing so much on the "bad kids it makes her realize how much she misses teaching those who do care" She talks about academics and children learning the lessons in her class more than any other teacher. There is a scene in the end when she says schools need more nurturing, but it starts at home, a place that she herself had not been spending enough time focusing on.
Throughout the movie the teachers spend some down time visiting in the lounge, they go out for drinks together, and that bonding between staff is something I agree with. Within this school there is no clear lines of who does what, or what is allowed. No consistency in a school can affect teachers, staff and students. Some teachers are appearing to be putting tons of effort into their class, while others appear to be lacking. The teachers in this movie complained and spoke more about each other than they did about teaching students. Even during the teacher of the year debate we heard topics including, copiers for every teacher, less faculty meetings, corporal punishment which had no relevancy to this school. The teachers were more passionate about improving their working conditions than improving the children's learning conditions.
Watching this movie made me realize that teachers are always faced with their own trial as they are human like anyone else, but the focus needs to remain on the students, learning, and especially bonding since students are much more willing to listen when they respect you.
Monday, March 4, 2013
sections 48-49 WS
48- Classification is a way to organize information about a certain topic or topics. You find things in common between a studied group and use them to bring organization to your essay. Classification sums up the way we use body paragraphs to present information in an essay. You want each paragraph to represent a certain characteristic, or topic of your essay. These body paragraphs come together to explain in detail the characteristics you may have researched or observed for your essay. In our upcoming essay number 3, we will be "arguing for a change or addition we would like to see in the k-12 curriculum". These changes must come from what we have seen in the movies Chalk and Superman. Since we will be using two different sources we will have to organize this essay with classification in order to present the facts clearly and argue our point.
49- Comparison/ Contrast I believe we will be using the information presented in this section to help us write about the two movies we have yet to watch at school. I will be making a list of similarities and differences to help me to organize my argument. I have a tendency to begin trailing off and getting off subject when one thing leads to another, and so on..... The sample provided in our book helps to give a clear idea of what our essays should sound like when being read; a presentation of information on the two movies, organized and/or classified to argue our point of what we believe should be different in the k-12 curriculum.
49- Comparison/ Contrast I believe we will be using the information presented in this section to help us write about the two movies we have yet to watch at school. I will be making a list of similarities and differences to help me to organize my argument. I have a tendency to begin trailing off and getting off subject when one thing leads to another, and so on..... The sample provided in our book helps to give a clear idea of what our essays should sound like when being read; a presentation of information on the two movies, organized and/or classified to argue our point of what we believe should be different in the k-12 curriculum.
challenges for students k-12
Brainstorming for paper # 3
What seems to be the biggest challenge for students k-12?
One challenge I think of right away is generalizing students. Teachers tend to generalize more in that age group than in college students. College students are at school by choice (in most cases) and usually they are of adult age. On the other hand k-12 students may be generalized or stereotyped because of many factors like the company they keep or the kind of learner they may be. These generalizations can be harmful to a child and may hold them back form their true potential.
Social anxiety, shyness, or introverted students can be a real challenge in the grades k-12. Many students who experience these things then tend to struggle with school work, or avoid school to avoid the uncomfortable scenarios. This is a challenge because it can be hard for a teacher to make a student feel at ease and the student may miss out on very important forming of fundamental skills.
Other challenges may come from a students home life. In k-12 students are expected to still reside with their parents, some may not be provided with a healthy home life to nurture and prepare a student for school each day. They may miss homework, or have the stresses of home carry through to their school day. This is a challenge for younger students because they may feel embarrassed or sad and go to great lengths to try and keep that a secret. This could greatly affect school along with many other scenarios that pose a challenge for younger students.
What seems to be the biggest challenge for students k-12?
One challenge I think of right away is generalizing students. Teachers tend to generalize more in that age group than in college students. College students are at school by choice (in most cases) and usually they are of adult age. On the other hand k-12 students may be generalized or stereotyped because of many factors like the company they keep or the kind of learner they may be. These generalizations can be harmful to a child and may hold them back form their true potential.
Social anxiety, shyness, or introverted students can be a real challenge in the grades k-12. Many students who experience these things then tend to struggle with school work, or avoid school to avoid the uncomfortable scenarios. This is a challenge because it can be hard for a teacher to make a student feel at ease and the student may miss out on very important forming of fundamental skills.
Other challenges may come from a students home life. In k-12 students are expected to still reside with their parents, some may not be provided with a healthy home life to nurture and prepare a student for school each day. They may miss homework, or have the stresses of home carry through to their school day. This is a challenge for younger students because they may feel embarrassed or sad and go to great lengths to try and keep that a secret. This could greatly affect school along with many other scenarios that pose a challenge for younger students.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)